Our friends at the Guardian are in the middle of a very interesting series on literary definitions, and recently Elizabeth Edmondson has taken issue with the distinction between literary and genre fiction: 

"Genre fiction" is a nasty phrase – when did genre turn into an adjective? But I object to the term for a different reason. It’s weasel wording, in that it conflates lit fic with literature. It was clever marketing by publishers to set certain contemporary fiction apart and declare it Literature – and therefore Important, Art and somehow better than other writing.

Jane Austen, she says, “never for a moment imagined she was writing Literature. Posterity decided that – not her, not John Murray, not even her contemporary readership. She wrote fiction, to entertain and to make money.”
Nine-tenths of me agrees with her.  No, more like 99/100 of me agrees with her — there’s just a tiny little Angry Nerd somewhere inside me who’s jumping up and down, stomping her tiny foot in rage and yelling at the lit-fic crowd to get off my lawn.  Anyhow, it’s a thoughtful, well-argued read, and you can see the rest of it here.
-Petra

Our friends at the Guardian are in the middle of a very interesting series on literary definitions, and recently Elizabeth Edmondson has taken issue with the distinction between literary and genre fiction: 

"Genre fiction" is a nasty phrase – when did genre turn into an adjective? But I object to the term for a different reason. It’s weasel wording, in that it conflates lit fic with literature. It was clever marketing by publishers to set certain contemporary fiction apart and declare it Literature – and therefore Important, Art and somehow better than other writing.

Jane Austen, she says, “never for a moment imagined she was writing Literature. Posterity decided that – not her, not John Murray, not even her contemporary readership. She wrote fiction, to entertain and to make money.”

Nine-tenths of me agrees with her.  No, more like 99/100 of me agrees with her — there’s just a tiny little Angry Nerd somewhere inside me who’s jumping up and down, stomping her tiny foot in rage and yelling at the lit-fic crowd to get off my lawn.  Anyhow, it’s a thoughtful, well-argued read, and you can see the rest of it here.

-Petra

Notes

  1. stargirl-lovegood reblogged this from nprbooks
  2. yashimas-interestingness reblogged this from nprbooks
  3. ravenomorrigan reblogged this from nprbooks
  4. vivalabiblioteca reblogged this from nprbooks and added:
    So, yes, THIS. It shouldn’t be a dirty, awful thing to read so-called “genre” fiction. (Really, why is genre an...
  5. scparris reblogged this from nprbooks
  6. alldragonsconsidered reblogged this from nprbooks
  7. rowena-the-raven reblogged this from nprbooks
  8. dangerousbooksforgirls reblogged this from nprbooks
  9. kaybee-in-la reblogged this from nprbooks
  10. meganalissa reblogged this from nprbooks
  11. ohainana reblogged this from allrightcallmefred
  12. hobospice32 reblogged this from nprbooks
  13. coopersgirl68 reblogged this from nprbooks
  14. lemonflats reblogged this from nprbooks
  15. kmk1701d reblogged this from nprbooks
  16. macchi-bou reblogged this from nprbooks
  17. fangirl4ever reblogged this from subversivegrrl